Reasonablematic: 5 Reasons Why Jay-Z & Nas Should Do An Album Together


Words by Tony Grands

Nas is rap music’s Rocky Balboa. Even when it seems like he’s getting beat, he’s still standing, receiving the punishment yet not going down. He’s undoubtedly Hip Hop’s man of the hour, & for a guy who is older than most of his competition, he’s in a real good spot right now.

At Nas’ record release party last week, him & Jay-Z were captured on film in what looked to be a couple of grizzled veterans sharing expensive laughs about the good old days. This made me wonder, “How long before the rumors of a possible Nas & Jay-Z album begin circling the rap-o-sphere?”

Why not get them started right here?

A Jay & Nas album would be monstrous & possibly bigger than Watch The Throne (Jay’s album with Kanye West) on a critically acclaimed level. Jay-Z is still the wordsmith he once was, just older & more multi-tasked, while Nas is slowly but surely reaffirming his spot as one of the genre’s highest regarded lyricists. A (super)group album would be a logical move for the rappers, a gracious offering to their devoted fans, & a steaming hot pot of bullshit for the haters to feast on.

I doubt this will ever come to fruition, but who knows. Stranger things have happened in rap music than two rivals joining forces. & if they need some encouragement, here a 5 reason why Jay-Z & Nas should do an album together.

5. Nothing To Lose
For what it’s worth, these two rappers have outlasted their contemporaries. The volume of their respective careers (even beyond just rapping on records) & catalogs (a combined 21 albums) put them light years ahead of MC’s that have been in the business just as long.

Both men have gone through trails & tribulation, both foreign & domestic, financial & personal. When the smoked cleared, they both stood, slightly wounded, but standing nonetheless. The only thing they can possibly lose by recording together is time. & that’s only if the outcome is bad. Otherwise, it’s a win-win for all parties involved, especially the fans & listeners.

4. Old Man Rap Isn’t Dead
Rap music is a young man’s sport, by virtue. Youth is what propels the narratives & stories about ignorance & ridiculous behavior, almost as an excuse for it. That’s what makes rap music so great. But a collaborative effort between the two top tier 30-something elder statesmen would ensure that Hip Hop’s more mature audience is still a viable one. Skinny jeans & face tattoos may be the uniform of today’s rap crowd, but that doesn’t mean Hip Hop’s adult sect is invisible. We outchea!

3. Settle The “Who Won?” Argument
The argument of who won between Nas & Jay-Z will be one that stands the test of time. This topic will never become weary or dated because the collective community seems to be split down the middle as to who the true victor was/is. Those who appreciate concise word dispersal vote Nas, while those who adhere more to reality rhymes claim Jay-Z to be victorious. That debate could easily get snuffed with 14 tracks of these ex-rivals tag-teaming music for an entire album.

Admittedly it could get boring & dissuade the listener who doesn’t already have a personal interest in either MC, but for the love of Hip Hop culture & rap music at large, a Nas/Jay-Z album would be historic & decisive.

2. Jay-Z Would Be Forced To Rap
Over the last 5-6 years, Jay has become more than just a rapper. Say what you will, but he has his hands across many tables, & only a fool would think that being the #1 rapper is high on his “to do” list. Fans of Jigga Man often complain that -over the years – he’s become complacent in his wealth & success. In fact, those same voices were out again with the release of Watch The Throne, saying all he rapped about was wealth & material prosperity. An album with Nasir would change all that.

If for nothing else than the respect of his peers & contemporaries, Jay-Z would have no choice but to write each rhyme like his rap life depended on it. Sure, he can pimp his restaurants & arenas & what not, but it’s hard to fool Hip Hop. Knowing that he’s doing an album with Nas should push him over the proverbial verbal top, even if only momentarily.

According to the ‘Net, that’s what his fans have been waiting for. His performance on Rick Ross’ “3 Kings” is an indicator that he still has “it,” whatever that means.

1. Set An Example Of Respect In The Rap Community
“Rap Beef” wasn’t always a dangerous thing. There was a time when a personal problem between rappers would result in a war of the words, & nothing more. While those days are apparently gone, Nas Vs. Jay-Z was the last real MC battle where it was taken to the studios & no further. Even as the tension increased with Jay-Z bringing Nas’ family into the music (condoms on the baby’s car seat), it didn’t escalate.

Years later, the two emerge as joint title holders of the sport with an odd, respect-layered friendship. & nobody was hurt in the process. Rap can get wild at times & maybe the leadership it lacks could be found in this imaginary record.

Words by Tony Grands


8 comments on “Reasonablematic: 5 Reasons Why Jay-Z & Nas Should Do An Album Together

  1. Capital G says:

    This idea is phenomenal and every point is extremely valid. Just for shits and giggles, who do you think “won” their battle?


    • Tony Grands says:

      I danced around this question for years…

      Overall, I think Jay-Z won that battle.

      Now that Nas is in a position of power & leverage again, I can admit that to myself. I had to defend my boy’s honor until I didn’t have to anymore. I wanted him to win, so he did.


      • Capital G says:

        There’s no way to agree without looking like a Grands Stan (there’s worse things to be by the way) but I always said Jay won strictly because of how vicious his words were. I mean for Christ’s sake his mom made him apologize his words were so venemous. I just had this convo with my man yesterday and he’s in the Nas camp because of Ether (while dope, it lacked the same sting as Jay’s response)

        @flawda – Go back and listen to Black Republican, a whole album of that would be the illest shit in history.


  2. flawda says:

    why would Jay waste his time doing this, he has no vested interest working with Nas. His career is clearly on a higher plateau than Nas at this stage, Nas would stand to benefit more than Jay-z. Jays moves are calculated nowadays, he doesn’t move backwards. Everything he does is to enhance his status and business.


  3. Curtis75Black says:

    #5 & 2 are the best reasons when it comes to this list. Neither has anything to lose when it comes down to getting busy in the booth together for a nice 15 track. I honesty didn’t like the last collabo they dropped on Nas “Hip Hop Is Dead” opus, so a real track put together would be large for me. #2 should’ve #1 to me, Jay would be forced to put it down seriously, especially if Nas is going in on every track. It’s something that would get the hearts pumping and it would be an instant classic off the name alone but the debate will continue to rage on between the two, which will never die.


  4. They lack chemistry on songs. It wouldn’t be a good idea. I’d rather see a Nas / AZ and Jay/ Scarface project


  5. Soulrise says:

    I would definitely want this album to happen but not for reasons #3 & #2. I already think Jay won easily so #3 isn’t much of a question for me (as I’ve told you before Grands I believe you can tell a lot about a person’s personality, priorities, outlook on life, etc. by who they feel won, lol).

    As for #2 I don’t think Jay’s stopped rapping. I know some people feel like he just rapped about the luxury lifestyle on WTT and phoned it in to let Kanye shine but when I listen to “No Church In The Wild”, “Who Gon Stop Me”, and “Murder To Excellence” to name a few I just don’t hear it.


  6. DV says:

    I never want to see this album happen. It would be like a Prince/Michael Jackson collabo which (thanks to Prince declining to be on MJ’s “Bad”) never happened (thank god). Besides Jay knows Nas is and always has been the king. When he couldnt get Nas for a guess verse early in his career (2x’s) he sampled him (2x’s). He was so much a Stan and was hurt by rejection he went and banged Nas BM. All the puss he can have and he pops her (not the greatest lookin chick)? That was intent.. Ether” is now common slang “Tookover” isnt. Jay-Z was obviously disturbed when he went on the radio and was at a lost for words. Nas didnt have to make a second diss song. One song was more then enough. Ether cut Jay so deep he had to go and “hit below the belt” with Super Ugly and then he apoligized which nullifies Superugly. As much bitches, hoes, and drug dealin Jay did in his rhymes to that point and Superugly is the song he finally decides to listen to his mom and apoligize? And plus he even admited defeat on Blueprint 2.


Comments, Questions, Or Criticism?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s